Why I’m boycotting Marvel’s ‘Doctor Strange’

Doctor Strnage Tibet.jpeg

The Internet has been over this before. In April, Marvel released the trailer for its next blockbuster superhero film, ‘Doctor Strange’, a story about an arrogant surgeon who, after his hands being irreperably damaged in an accident, learns the error of his ways and becomes a powerful scorcerer. Stephen Strange finds his spiritual awakening in Tibet, with the help of a Tibetal mystic known as the Ancient One, and thereafter protects the world from all forms of mystic badness as the Sorcerer Supreme.

Marvel’s first trailer brought accusations of white-washing after it appeared to show that the huge studio, now owned by Disney, has scrubbed all mention of Tibet from the story. In the film, Tibet has become Nepal and the Ancient One is now a white person. The reason seems obvious: to appease the government of the People’s Republic of China, a country that represents a huge cinemagoing audience and has the world’s most notorious wall of censorship, forbidding any mention of politically-sensitive situations like Tibet.

I won’t re-tread old ground too much, but link to some articles here:

(Lionsroar.com) The Strange Case of Doctor Strange’s Tibet

(The Guardian) Tilda Swinton cast as Tibetan to placate China, says Doctor Strange writer

‘Doctor Strange’ Writer Says China-Tibet Remarks Don’t Represent Marvel

(Screenrant.com) Doctor Strange’s Erasure Of Tibet Is A Political Statement

(The Guardian) George Takei on Doctor Strange controversy: ‘Marvel must think we’re all idiots’

If you didn’t know, Tibet is technically part of China – ever since China invaded and stomped all over Tibet in the 1950s, and has been crushing it underfoot ever since. Before I get accused of exaggeration, let the world be reminded of an independant ICJ  Human Rights Report into the brutalities of the 1950-51 invasion of Tibet, which led to the exile of the Tibetan government, its spiritual leader the Dalai Lama, and over 100,000 desperate citizens. The illegal and well-guarded path over the freezing Himalayas has killed many fleeing Tibetans. They were and purportedly are still escaping beatings, brainwashing (thabzing), wrongful arrests and killings, torture,  mutilation, dismemberment, disembowelling, vivisection and crucifixion (yes, you read that correctly). Following the 1959 uprising, those shouting “Long live the Dalai Lama” were reported to have their tongues torn out with meathooks.

Children have been spirited away from villages to be indoctrinated at Chinese schools. Han Chinese have been urged/bribed to move into the “Tibet Autonomous Region”, displacing the native Tibetans an attempt at cultural erasure. Thousands of Buddhist monasteries were looted and destroyed (purportedly 8 of 6,000 remaining, as Potemkin tourist attractions), and celibate Buddhist monks were forced to have sex and marry one another. Nomads with generations of nomadic existence in their blood were told to stay put. Communism brought famine to the near-barren lanscape of the Tibetan plateau.

In Tibet, people are punished just for keeping in touch with their exiled relatives, even though this is now official legal. Self immolators who protest the enslavement of Tibet are thrown, still burning, into trucks and disappear, and may take a day to die. During the 2008 Tibetan uprising, which failed, bodies of protestors were piled high in the courtyards of monasteries. 1.5 million Tibetans have died in defence of their human rights. I’d heard stories, but the facts I found this year when researching my latest novel about Buddhism and Tibet made me sick to my stomach.

But Marvel wants to make money off its latest film, so it continues to pander to the Chinese film requirements. Censors in China only approve 34 foreign films per year, and some censorship requires that a film contains a scene set in China, has the casting of Chinese actors, has Chinese investors, or shows “positive Chinese messages”. Marvel already got into bed with Chinese film studios for ‘Iron Man 3’ to avoid those requirements (and, incidentally, adding additional scenes in which genius Chinese surgeons fix a superhero’s heart problems, adding Chinese product placement, and changing the Chinese villain The Mandarin to a British actor ‘playing’ a villain with a false American accent). You might have noticed a rash of films the last few years with scenes set in China or in which China saves the day, such as Looper (2012), Red Dawn (2012), Gravity (2013), Transformers: Age of Extinction (2014), and The Martian (2015). Why? Because this doubles box office profits from China, as well as allows the film to be shown in the first place. Forget politics, there’s dough to be made.

Weirdly, in the latest comic book issue of Doctor Strange, Marvel has confirmed the Tibetan origin:

untitled

Doctor Strange #011 (Sept 2016)

What’s going on there? Appeasement to fans? A small sacrifice, considering the films are making far, far more money than any comic book run ever could. Not good enough, Marvel.

I don’t know about you guys, but kowtowing to a tyrannical government for profit in light of genocide and cultural suppression sounds pretty uncool to me. If you’ve read my previous travel posts you’ll know that I have a lot of love for historical and present day China, but I despise its government. I have a great love of Marvel, whose comics and characters have brought me some of my greatest joys in life, but I can’t in good conscience see a film I’ve always hoped to be made, with actors I adore. I was hoping that the newly-released second trailer might correct some assumptions – but sadly not. And already people seem to have forgotten about the controversy and are all set to pre-order their tickets. I don’t blame them – but I would blame myself.

—db

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Why I’m boycotting Marvel’s ‘Doctor Strange’

  1. this is utter what business does do marvel or disney have in politics?
    what right do they have to deprave millions of people from their great movie just to make a political statement?

    sure, Tibet’s oppression is no secret. and it is quite known how horribly they suffer.
    but collectively punishing the chainese people for some their tyrannical goverment does is sheer stupidity?

    what could marvel and disney possibly hope to achieve by making their movies un-publishable in chaina??

    this is not greed. this is basic common sense

    Like

    • Hi Yosef,

      Thanks for reading and sharing your thoughts, I appreciate it and value other opinions.

      I suppose there are a few points to consider. The first is that you say Tibet’s oppression is widely known. I disagree – I rarely speak to people, even in the UK where the media is considered to be generally open for all, who know much about the Tibet situation at all. Often they are aware that there were some problems, and that the Dalai Lama comes from Tibet, and that it probably relates to China in some way, but the details often allude them. I have fairly wide social circles and am often surprised at how little people know about the situation. The truth is that it’s not widely discussed by the general media because it’s embarassing to China, a major economic partner and possible global security threat, and because it’s old news.

      In terms of Marvel/Disney, I can’t deny that it’s common sense for them to pander to China. When you say “basic commons sense”, perhaps you’ll agree that in this context we’re talking about “good business sense”. Marvel/Disney are a business and the objective of a business is to make money. Blocking off a huge market like China would indeed lose them a great deal of income. Is this ‘greedy’ of them? I agree: not in principle. Do they have an obligation to get political? Not at all.

      But this is not about obligation or good business – it’s a question of morality, and whether very influential powers choose to ignore ethically deplorable acts that have affected 150,000 people or more for the sake of finances. My issue is that Marvel/Disney are skirting a sensitive topic (a simple word that undermines genocide and ethnic/cultural cleansing) in return for cash. They are choosing money over morality. I believe that this is wrong. You ask if this is a good enough reason to deprive a whole country of good entertainment. Don’t forget, Marvel/Disney is a business – it’s not their business just to entertain – they aren’t a charity. Their business is to make money, like any business, and they do that VIA great entertainment. By asking that question, you are choosing entertainment over ethical responsibility. I believe that this is wrong too.

      Marvel would lose a percentage of their income (the rest of the world can still buy tickets, and China doesn’t HAVE to block a SLIGHTLY politically sensitive film from being shown in their cinemas), but they are doing something that is morally laudible. Business do this all the time nowadays – they lose money by being ecologically responsible, for example, or supporting major humanitarian charities. Governments also lose out economically by placing trade embargoes on countries that commit “human crimes”. I don’t think it’s a lot to ask for a superrich giant like Disney to do the right thing by NOT corrupting their original source material, thereby spitting in the face of suffers of genocide and displacement, for the sake of money.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s